Why F&B Peak Execution Falls Short

This is the second article in a three-part blog series drawn from the webinar, How Food, Beverage, and Alcohol Distributors Turn Known Demand into Protected Margin. In the first article, we looked at where promotional planning breaks down for F&B distributors and what a clean process requires. In this article, we look at why seasonal peaks, as predictable as they are, still strain buying and warehouse operations.

***

On paper, peak season should be the easiest part of the year to plan for. The demand is known. The dates don't move. Thanksgiving falls where it always falls, back-to-school starts when school starts, and summer velocity for beer and cider shows up like clockwork. In practice, plenty of F&B distributors still get caught flat-footed, not because the demand surprised them, but because the operation underneath it wasn't built to absorb it. Jenn Meinders, VP of Purchasing at Martin Bros. Distributing, put it simply: “It's predictable seasonal demand, but the challenge is twofold.”

Turning supplier risk and warehouse capacity into a forward-buying advantage

Meinders' team runs a 99.5% service level at a broadline food service distributor by treating peak season as something to get ahead of, rather than react to. “We want to make sure we're ahead of it,” she said. “While we have a platform that's exceptional, and it'll do what we need it to do when we need it to do it, we forward-buy into that period in order to plan for the possible shortfall from our vendors, because there's a lot of people in my boat that are all doing the same thing at the same time.” Forward-buying ahead of the industry-wide rush is what protects her service level before the season even starts.

Her team also turns a physical constraint into a freight advantage. “We can't build millions of dollars’ worth of inventory and have it all come in one day,” Meinders said. “It's got to be staggered.” Rather than treating that as a limitation, her team uses the staggered receiving window deliberately, converting smaller, frequent orders on high-velocity items into full truckload buys for better freight economics on inventory they already know they'll need.

Why forecasting beats post-casting

Mike Mills, Solutions Architect Lead at Blue Ridge, put his finger on exactly why Meinders' team plans the way it does: "You need a system that isn't post-casting, but forecasting. Post-casting assumes what happened last year is going to happen again this year, and we know that's not true. You need a system that can look forward, and uses machine learning algorithms to sift through that data and understand what the future is going to look like”

Meinders' team puts that forward-looking approach into practice every season: school-season demand shifts based on how the prior school year ended and began; government regulations change, menus change from one year to the next. Some seasons, like Thanksgiving turkey or St. Patrick's Day cabbage and potatoes, are close to fixed and need little judgment layered on top. Back-to-school takes more real human interpretation of what's actually different this year, backed by a platform built to look ahead rather than just repeating the past.

Meinders described exactly who makes that call on her team, and why: “We've got a lot of historical information about our supplier partners, too, and we know who traditionally stumbles during this period, and who traditionally is able to fill it. So that judgment does come from an experienced buying team, and I trust them to make their decisions. I'm lucky.”

Mills summed up the balance well: “Buying is part science and part art. You've got tools, and the technology does all of the calculations for you, but there's still the art of buying based on what they know to be true, because there might be stuff that's not reflected in the data.”

Spotting a true trend and correcting course when you miss one

Telling a true seasonal trend from a short-term spike is a skill in its own right, and Brian Bennett has a clear read on what separates the buyers who get it from the ones who don't. “Any experienced buyer can spot a true seasonal demand pattern,” Bennett said. “It's when you're looking at the specific months that aren't the repeatable pattern, identifying whether this was a promotion last year in a specific month, or the month before, or the month after. So you have a new promotion this year: what month is it falling into relative to the prior years? And then, how are you going to utilize you supply chain planning platform to adjust to what you need?” Getting that call right protects a distributor's margin all season long. Get it wrong, Bennett said, and “you're stuck with inventory for months, and nobody likes that.”

Even when a read does get missed, Bennett was clear that the response isn't just absorbing the loss and moving on: "What tools do you have in place in your planning platform to help you with adjusting those figures, so you go into next year well prepared for that potential issue that you may be running into?" That's the difference between a miss that costs you once and a miss that quietly costs you every year after — and it's what closes the gap: a planning platform that lets you correct the figures going forward, not just note what went wrong.

4 questions to ask before your next seasonal peak

The teams that navigate seasonal peaks well aren't the ones buying the most, the earliest, and stuffing every branch with inventory. They're the ones asking sharper questions before the season starts:

1. What's our supplier shortfall risk this peak, and how much do we need to forward-buy to cover it?
2. Can our warehouse receive this volume, or does it need to be staggered over several weeks?
3. What changed since last year that could make last year's numbers a misleading guide?
4. Is this a true seasonal pattern, or a one-time promotion that happened to land in the same window last time?

The Blue Ridge platform is built around exactly the distinction Mills draws above: forecasting forward, not post-casting backward. That's what frees an experienced buying team to spend its judgment on the calls that need it, which suppliers stumble and which seasons need real interpretation, instead of redoing math a system should already be handling for them.

As Mike Mills put it in closing the webinar discussion, the real challenge isn't seeing a promotional calendar or a seasonal peak coming; it's having planning operations built to act on it before the season catches you short.  

‍

In the third and final article in this series, we'll look at how F&B distributors protect margin as freight costs, tariffs, and shifting category trends squeeze profitability that many teams assumed was safe.

Watch the full webinar: How Food, Beverage, and Alcohol Distributors Turn Known Demand into Protected Margin

‍